Posted by: John Elliott | May 16, 2009

Big surprise win for Congress – BJP and Mayawati do badly – Communists routed

Where else in the world could you have a clear general election result within three hours of vote counting starting! India did that this morning with its electronic voting and counting system.

Based on both actual results and leads by the end of the day,  the UPA coalition led by the Congress Party is back in power.

It looks like getting an amazing total of 262 seats, almost at the half-way mark of 272 needed for a majority in the 543 Lok Sabha (lower house) elected seats with extra allies.

The BJP has conceded defeat, with its NDA grouping getting only 157 seats. L.K.Advani, 81, has said he wants to resign as the party leader. .

Congress alone looks like getting 206 seats, which is its best result since 1991. It is a stunningly better result anyone expected – around 180 was the most that even the most optimistic Congress leaders hoped for.

This significantly reduces the power of regional parties, which had hoped to be able to have a big influence on the new government’s formation and policies.

Congress will now be able to:

1.  Form a much more stable government than it has had for the past five years – and enormously more stable that had been forecast by election pundits.

2.  Appoint a much better quality cabinet, without having to accept as many highly corrupt ministers from regional parties as Manmohan Singh had in the last government – especially in lucrative infrastructure and transport ministries.

3.  Implement economic policies without being held back by the communist-led Left, as it has been for most of the past five years – the election result will pull in foreign and domestic investment and help the economy to ride the current international crisis.

The Left is doing very badly in both West Bengal and Kerala, its two major power centres, and elsewhere. It looks like winning only 24 seats overall compared with 59 last time and will not be a significant force in the new parliament.

Manmohan Singh is the first Indian prime minister since Jawaharlal Nehru to be returned to power in a consecutive government after serving a full five year term.

Even though he has had little real authority, with Sonia Gandhi, leader of both Congress and the NPA, being in overall charge, his air of respectable stability has contributed to the election result.

The result also shows that Congress is re-emerging as a real national party. Credit for that will go mainly to Rahul Gandhi, Sonia’s son and heir apparent for the party leadership and prime minister’s job, as well as to Manmohan Singh.

Rahul was specially influential in Congress’s campaign in Uttar Pradesh (UP), the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty’s traditional political base. Congress is winning in some 21 seats in UP, its best result for 25 years in a state where it had been virtually written off.

That has contributed to the failure of Mayawati, the Dalit (“untouchable” in the caste system) chief minister of UP, to emerge with her BSP political party as  a significant country-wide politician and potential prime minister.

The Indian and international media have vastly over-hyped the national importance of this egocentric politician, but the voters have thought differently – her party is winning only in 20 seats compared with ambitions for 30-40 or more.

The regional Trinamool Congress, linked with Congress,  is doing historically well in West Bengal, taking more than half the parliamentary seats from the CPI(M)-led Left Front that has imposed its rule – often a rule of terror – throughout the state for over 30 years.

As was clear when I went walking round West Bengal villages with Dinesh Trivedi, the Trinamool candidate in Barrackpur, people are no longer scared to come out and criticise the CPI(M). And that could well lead to the Left losing its 32-year long rule of the state assembly in 2011.

In Orissa, the Biju Janata Dal (BJD) party led by Naveen Patnaik is doing well, comfortably beating its rivals both for control of the State assembly and its MPs.

It looked after the polls as if Patnaik was not doing as well as it had appeared when I visited the constituency. But his BJD is winning comfortably – being rewarded for a good image, especially of caring for the poor, even if his state government achieved little in real terms.

It’s been a dramatic day of unexpected election results – with three major trends:

–  the re-emergence of a self-confident Congress, especially in UP;

–  a major reversal in fortunes for the Communist Left, marking the end of its 32-year iron grip on West Bengal;

–  Rahul Gandhi proving himself as a national politician, earning a role at the top.

An earlier version of this post is on



  1. I’m ecstatic about the results. This proves critics of the Gandhis wrong: they may be a dynasty, but there is no doubt that they have done more than their predecessors (barring Nehru) in democratising the party. At some point people have to stop holding their background against them; the point is….what are they using it for – personal gain or national interest?

    And I am thrilled that the electorate has given Dr. Singh a clear mandate. He is the best person for the job.

    syngal: couldn’t agree with you more about the dmk. But I’m afraid we’re stuck with these guys: Azhagiri is the least qualified and the most corrupt, but he’s bound to get a cabinet berth. Sigh.

  2. A great verdict for stability, and continuity without some of the previous heavy baggage of the past coalition. If you believe in democracy, with all its frustrations, then you have to accept that a verdict reflects the will of the people. A lot of the external media including your column has been dismissive and churlish about the elections in India. We can’t mimic the UK or the USA, nor is it germane to the very heterogeneous character of India. This mandate has been sufficiently uniform across India that it is no fluke; and to imply that the lead campaigners and PM deserve credit.

    Thanks Oracle in your ivory tower in the hills – but you are wrong! I have never been “dismissive and churlish about the elections in India” – about politicians, their electoral corruption and lack of policy issues yes, but not about the fact that they work and produce important results! je

  3. great result, if only he is able to shed the corrupt ministers; especially from the dmk.

    at least we hope to see stability and cleaner government than before with regional satraps often calling the shots for providing the support.

    good luck upa, syngal

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: