Posted by: John Elliott | September 14, 2012

Manmohan Singh responds to critics with symbolic reforms

Stung by increasingly sharp criticism at home and abroad, the Indian government today announced a raft of foreign direct investment (FDI) reforms in supermarkets, airlines and other areas that ended three years of policy inertia. This followed a highly controversial decision yesterday to cut fuel subsidies, triggering a 12% increase in diesel retail prices and restrictions on the sale of cooking gas.

“If we have to go down, we have to go down fighting,” Manmohan Singh, the prime minister, said at the cabinet meeting that took the decisions, anticipating opposition from within his coalition which could reduce the government’s parliamentary majority. It was time, he said, “for big bang reforms”.


Complaining about the decisions that have caused a political furore tonight, a BJP spokesman said they had been taken “under foreign pressure” – and he was probably correct!

I hesitate to suggest that foreign correspondents based in New Delhi provoked Manmohan Singh into action, but there is no doubt that sharp criticisms in  The Washington Post, The Economist and Time magazine, among others, have struck home.

More importantly, there are growing risks of India being downgraded by international rating agencies because of a high fiscal deficit with economic growth slowing to as low as 5.5%.

The media reports have focused on the prime minister’s lack of leadership and action. Simon Denyer described him in the Post last week as “a dithering, ineffectual bureaucrat presiding over a deeply corrupt government” who “remained silent as his cabinet colleagues filled their own pockets” – a reference to the coal industry and other corruption scandals that have involved government ministers.

Manmohan Singh’s 80th birthday

Today’s decisions mean that the prime minister can look forward to kinder reviews on September 26, his 80th birthday.

They will also help to divert attention from the coal corruption scandal that has dominated the headlines in recent weeks.

The FDI announcements have been widely praised, but they are much more significant for their symbolism and impact on market sentiment than for any rapid direct economic effect. They show that the government is willing to dare coalition partners – notably Mamata Banerjee of the West Bengal-based Trinamool Congress – to oppose the changes and even withdraw from the coalition.

Taken with the fuel price hike, they also seem to show that Manmohan Singh is prepared to do things that may not necessarily meet the approval of Sonia Gandhi, his political boss at the head of the coalition, and her son Rahul, though their views are not known.

Food distribution

The main FDI change is that, after years of debate, supermarket companies (dubbed multi-brand retail) such as Wal-Mart and Tesco can have a 51% equity stake in Indian retail joint ventures. This could have an impact within a few years, but it is not relevant to the immediate recovery of India’s economy. The measure has been opposed by many parties for populist political reasons focussed on the impact that it could have on small shopkeepers and street-sellers.

The real opposition has however been generated by public sector agencies and middlemen, who dominate the inefficient and waste-ridden distribution system between farmers and the shops. These vested interests are the main target of the reform. To placate opposition, the government has said that individual states can decide whether to allow the FDI, which means that it will not happen in perhaps half the states, at least for some time.

There are positive requirements that the joint ventures must spend half their investment on rural-based distribution systems to serve the retail outlets that they are now to be allowed to open, and source 30% of their products from Indian small and medium sized firms.

Indian companies such as Reliance and the Future Group have failed to break the grip of the current distribution operators, so it remains to be seen how successful foreign retailers can be, working with their Indian partners – they will be helped by changes in distribution regulations that states opting in are likely to introduce.


A decision to allow foreign airlines to take up to 49% stakes in Indian airlines (subject to regulatory arrangements) also needs to be seen in context. The government is not pushing something it specially believes in. It is partly reacting to market conditions, but has mainly been influenced by a change in the attitude of India’s leading private airlines, notably Jet Airways that has managed to block the initiative for some 15 years.

Jet seems to have withdrawn its opposition, and FDI is now favoured by airlines that urgently need fresh capital, notably Kingfisher which is near to financial collapse, Spice Jet and GoAir. Foreign airlines based in the Gulf are expected to be most interested in exploring possible stakes – led maybe by Emirates which already has a big 20% share of India’s outbound air traffic, and Qatar Airways.

The government also raised FDI limits for broadcasting and introduced it for electricity power trading exchanges, and announced small equity divestment plans of around 10% for five public sector corporations – Oil India, Hindustan Copper, NALCO (aluminium), MMTC (metals trading) and RITES (transport projects).

Rahul Gandhi next?

The next attention-diverting announcement will probably be a ministerial reshuffle, plus Congress Party changes including a new party post for Rahul Gandhi, dynastic heir to the party leadership, whose failure to impress so far has been matched only by that of the government.

This could come next week, according to media reports. It will then be up to Rahul to show whether this appointment is mere symbolism, or whether he can grow sufficiently in stature to become a prime ministerial candidate.

He might also tell people whether he believes in the sort of economic reform announcements made yesterday and today, or whether subsidies and other pro-poor policies are much more important because he thinks they are most likely to help his Congress Party do well in elections.


  1. Hopefully, the indian national congress will be the cause of the undoing of democracy in india.

    If there is a case against democracy, the INC is it. The undoing is a given but i only pray that it happens in my lifetime.

  2. John, This is a case of game keepers turn poachers. These very people like Manmohan, Montek who term themselves the prophets of reforms, but were also the architects of the isolationist policies that were pursued all these years. What use all this afer bringing us to this ruinous state of affaires. They are also the killers of the PSUs by having a strangle hold on their functioning, no autonomy, no board governance. Why blame the PSUs, they are the killers for everything that ails PSUs. On FDI, the less said the better. This 26%, 49% etc is all crony capitalism to encash their equities after a while. who are they fooling. all these fellows like Bharti et al will cash out at premiums. Let everything be made 100% foreign controlled. It would test the gumption of the likes of walmart et al if they have the guts to take on all alone. They also play games, they have no real appetite, should they have let them ask for 100% and stop this crony capitalism of cashing of sweat equities of politicians and promoters alike. after all all these jokers have their hands elsewhere. when would their appetite for making money be over is the question that begets an answer. They have collectively ruined the country and continue to do so.

    why can not these geriatics just give up? They have no right or morality to govern. They have looted us

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: