Posted by: John Elliott | January 26, 2015

A shouting economic adviser, a veteran Nobel Laureate and a rock star missile scientist on stage at the Jaipur lit fest

Arvind Panagaria, one of India’s top economic advisers, has a short fuse and shouts. Eighty-two year old V.S.Naipaul, the Nobel prize winning author, has given what might turn out to be his last long interview, and Abdul Kalam, the 83-year old space and missile scientist who became India’s president, is greeted by young Indians like a rock star.

These are a few of the big-name impressions from the tenth annual Jaipur Literature Festival that ended yesterday after a magnificent five days in Rajasthan’s historical pink city. The total number of footfalls (including repeat visitors) reached 255,000, up from about 220,000 last year, and as usual included masses of school children

Naipaul DondyNaipaul is a Trinidad-born British citizen of Indian origin who wrote two scathing books on his early visits to India – An Area of Darkness and A Wounded Civilisation in the 1960s and 1970s.

Clearly frail and sitting in a wheel-chair for a slow but revealing interview with the UK-based writer Farrukh Dondy (right), he told a crowd of several thousand people that he first “came to India out of curiosity about my ancestral land”, with little idea what he would write.

When his India books caused controversy, his mother told him “please leave India to the Indians”. He didn’t take her advice and years later gave the country a more positive verdict.

The most remarkable of the three impressions was the rock star (there is no other adequate description) welcome given to Kalam (below), who was mobbed by screaming youngsters, blocking the festival throughways.

I found it difficult to get anyone to tell me why the diminutive rather quaint-looking Kalam, with his carefully manicured floppy white hair, should beat even a top film star in iconic status. Eventually, one of the festival’s dozens of young volunteers who keep the world’s largest free lit fest running smoothly told me, “He has achieved something technical”.

This was a reference to important work on ballistic missiles and launch vehicle technology done by Kalam who was known as India’s “missile man” and became the country’s highly respected president in 2002. He also played a leading role in India’s 1998 nuclear weapon tests. Some critics say that Kalam’s actual scientific achievements are over-stated, but whether that is true or not, he has become a legend and an inspiration to the young.

Chatting with the volunteer, it became clear he felt that, unlike most self-serving politicians and many public figures, Kalam has done tangible work as a scientist and an engineer. Kalam also appears as a modest man who wants to inspire the youth – he launched a What Can I Give movement in 2011 and frequently addresses young audiences.


“If four things are followed-having a great aim, acquiring knowledge, hard work and perseverance then anything can be achieved,” he said at the festival, adding that he had addressed 19.5m youth in the past 20 years and urged them to become “unique”.

Panagariya’s (below) demonstration of his apparent short fuse is significant because he has just returned from an academic life in the US to run Narendra Modi’s revamped Planning Commission, which is called the NITI Aayog or National Institution for Transforming India. Maybe he found being contradicted by a leading Indian journalist rather harder to accept than being challenged by American students!

arvindpanagriyaFor several minutes he had a shouting argument in Hindi with Om Thanvi, editor of the Jansatta newspaper, who disagreed with his claims about how much Rajasthan’s economic development and social indicators compared with other states, and whether it no longer qualified to be called a BIMARU state (an acronym coined some years ago to bracket the backward states of Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Uttar Pradesh).

Panagaria has been an economic adviser to the Rajasthan government and was frustrated by Thanvi’s arguments that were based on an article in India’s highly respected Economic and Political Weekly.

Thanvi also criticised the Rajasthan government’s recent controversial decision to ban people who do not have specified educational qualifications from standing as candidates in panchayat (village) elections. Panagariya backed the decision and became so agitated that he stood up and demanded solutions from Thanvi, shouting, “If Mr Editor has any better formula we are ready to implement it. I am even ready to bow and touch his feet if he has any better suggestion”.

Amazon ousts local bookshop

With over 300 speakers at six concurrent sessions during the day and over 150 musicians for evening entertainment, the festival has become a major international fixture on the literary scene since it began ten years ago. Every year, the distinguished old Diggi Palace venue is adjusted and enlarged to accommodate the growing crowds.

This year, the only negative development was that Delhi’s Full Circle book shop was ousted from running the festival’s shop by, which outbid its financial down payment. This is a sad example of foreign financial muscle ( has $2bn to spend) defeating local enterprise, and it turned out badly because the Amazon shop was drab and badly stocked.

Wal-Mart or Tesco (who, like Amazon, also sell books) could not have done a worse job. A real bookseller, not a general on-line store with little real books expertise, ought to re-appear next year.

This article appears on


  1. What was Shri Om Thanvi’s response to Professor Panagaria’s ‘challenge’ to suggest something better than what he has advised the govt. of Rajasthan to do? It must have been quite educative/interesting for the litterateurs present to watch Professor Panagaria’s ‘shouting’. Losing one’s cool may be the appropriate response by the person who is going to transform this country to comments that are not to his liking.

  2. The report is short but educative .Some technical fault in my IPad prevented me from viewing the photos but I will try again later. I also failed to know whether any other Hindi writers, apart from Thanviji, were there and how they contributed to the festival, ajitkumar

  3. Fine piece. I will add that at the heart of Kalam’s rock star appeal is not his ‘technical’ achievements but what people, especially youngsters, see as his earnest efforts to engage people on issues of personal and professional development, his readiness to offer solutions and his simple and spartan lifestyle. Used to self-important and curt manners of the high and mighty, Indians find Kalam refreshingly simple and easy-going despite his many achievements.

  4. John Elliot is marketing his book “Implosion” on India’s tryst with the Nehru-Gandhis. Here he takes a look at the Jaipur Lit. Fest. He was not impressed with Panagariya’s shouting match with an Indian journalist over whether Rajasthan is sick. Elliot is right. Debating in the US assumes certain social norms and etiquette that is hard to come by in the slums born from India’s destiny. India is constructed to test the patience and pillory the righteousness of any cultured gentleman. I speak from personal experience.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: