Posted by: John Elliott | October 6, 2018

Exit of two women who broke Indian banks’ glass ceiling

Chanda Kochhar has left ICICI after 34 years

Part of what was chauvinistically dubbed ICICI’s “petticoat brigade” 

The resignation this week of Chanda Kochhar, the chief executive of ICICI Bank, has terminated the impressive career of India’s top woman banker, while illustrating how easy it is to become snared in the country’s crony business world of shady liaisons and deals that straddle the borders of ethics and good corporate practice.

Kochhar (below), age 56 and widely described as “feisty”, had been with the bank for all of her 34-year career. She had been the chief executive since 2009 and could maybe have risen to further heights in India’s financial world if she had not been caught in conflicts of interest with her businessman husband and a company that does not shine in the league tables of Indian corporates.

Her apparently forced departure, after taking indefinite leave in June, brings to an end a remarkable rise in the early 2000s of women bankers in ICICI, India’s second largest private sector bank. Breaking the glass ceiling  women held 13 of the top 40 management posts just over a decade ago, had three of five executive board seats, and ran two of five subsidiaries.

Chanda K.JPG“Almost all the leaders we have picked have succeeded and most have been women,” K.V.Kamath, then ICICI’s (male) managing director and ceo, told me in September 2006, when I wrote about them in Fortune magazine. He had been responsible for empowering them, mostly when they were young.

Once dubbed the “petticoat brigade” by Mumbai’s chauvinistic banking fraternity, these highly competitive women helped build ICICI into a business that became famed for its aggressive risk-taking attitude and for its growth from a sleepy and bureaucratic development institution into India’s most widely diversified and customer-oriented bank.

Kochhar told me then that she knew nothing about retail banking when she became head of ICICI Bank’s fledgling retail operations in 1998 at the edge of 36. That made “Citi and others think we were doing a small flirtation”, she said. In April 2006, she was made head of corporate banking, then a small activity, and later that year figured for the second time in Fortune’s list of top 50 international busineswomen.

Now the tables have turned and she is the third top private sector banker to have their jobs curtailed in recent months.

Earlier this year it was announced that Shikha Sharma (below), Kochhar’s former ICICI colleague and rival , will leave Axis Bank, the third largest private sector lender, in December. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) opposed her reappointment as chief executive after Axis Bank’s non-performing assets (NPAs) rose by more than 300% in three years.

617996-sharma-shikha-101817.jpgMore intriguing is the RBI saying that Yes Bank, the fourth largest, should not renew the contract next January of its chief executive, Rana Kapoor, 61, who was one of the bank’s two founders in 2004. His co-founder, Ashok Kapur, was killed in the 2008 Mumbai terror attacks. Again, bad loans were the problem – the RBI said that Yes Bank had under-reported its bad loans for two years. Kapoor also hit the headlines in 2014 when, for unexplained reasons, he refused to allow Kapur’s widow (and his sister-in-law) or her daughter to be appointed to the board.

It is worth noting that, while the RBI’s action on these private sector banks reflects a long-needed assault on the banking system’s failings, it has also helped to deflect attention from public sector banks that have been heavily criticised for poor management and regulatory controls.

The criticisms escalated early this year when an alleged $1.77bn corporate fraud emanated from the government’s owned Punjab National Bank and the businessman involved, jeweller Nirav Modi fled abroad.

News of Kochhar’s alleged conflicts of interest, that were started by a whistle-blower over a year ago, built up shortly after that. She had led a big expansion of ICICI’s retail and corporate banking, more than doubling the bank’s assets, but she then presided over a sharp increase in non-performing corporate loans.

One of the defaulters was Videocon Industries, a diversified group controlled by Venugopal Dhoot, who had done business deals with Kochhar’s husband, Deepak Kochhar involving an energy company. This led to questions about the transactions, which included Chanda Kochhar failing to recuse herself from a loan committee that approved a $440m Videocon loan in 2012 as part of a multi-bank consortium.

Ironically I was told in 2006 that one of the basic reasons why there were so many women was that, while they enjoyed working in the ICICI environment, their husbands were the main money earners (almost all those in the top levels were married). The wives could therefore afford to enjoy job fulfilment without worrying about ICICI’s then low pay levels that were in the bottom 25% of the country’s banks.

An era is ending with the departure of Kochhar and Sharma, but their removal along with Kapoor shows that the RBI has at last had begun to deal with the enormous mountain of banks’ bad assets and broader issues. If it continues with the work, more skeletons will emerge because India’s corporate sector is riddled with corporate cronyism and a lack of ethics.


  1. It is good to know that the RBI has finally got the guts to do something about bank management when performance is poor – but scandalous that standing aside as you say from the disastrous crony ridden and politically protected public sector banks, the first victims of the current campaign are women who have succeeded in the private sector.

    As the former head of a European bank office in India, I should like to go on record as having found in the 90s that Chandra Kochar and her then boss Lalita Gupte were highly competent in their field and that to discuss a project with them was a breath of fresh air in comparison with the sluggish lack of interest of almost any manager in the public sector. Interestingly the exception to this was the RBI, which incisdentally also had some smart senior women executives.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: